Panel, then unit
A cold electric heater in Sleepy Valley is often the breaker, so the panel is the first stop. A breaker that holds while the tank stays cold points inside: element, thermostat or the high-limit cut-out. One that trips again immediately points at a shorted element or wiring fault.
Lukewarm rather than cold is a different signature: on a two-element tank it usually means the upper circuit has failed, so the top of the tank never heats and the lower element works slowly to warm what it can.
What the visit tests
Resistance and continuity on the elements, voltage at the thermostat, the high-limit switch, the wiring and connections, and the breaker sizing. Each circuit is tested separately, because the symptoms overlap until they are measured.
Safety, and hard water
The breaker comes off before covers are opened, the unit is confirmed dead, and the element is disturbed only once the water is drained below it — a dry element powered for a minute is scrap. On water measuring 240 mg/L of calcium carbonate, elements also scale and lose efficiency before they fail, which is why recovery fades gradually.