Elements, thermostats, supply
An electric tank is a simple machine, and its failures are simple too. In Pico the water adds one wrinkle: at 240 mg/L of calcium carbonate, elements scale up and lose their ability to transfer heat long before they fail outright, so recovery slows gradually and nobody notices until the showers get short.
The element. A scaled element heats poorly; a cracked one trips the breaker or blows the high-limit cut-out. A failed lower element leaves the top of the tank hot and the rest cold.
The thermostat. One that reads wrong keeps the tank too cool or lets it overheat until the high-limit cuts. Reset it once; if it pops again, the thermostat or element is the reason.
Breaker and wiring. A loose connection at the heater, a burnt wire nut or an undersized breaker produces intermittent faults that look like element failures, so those get inspected rather than assumed.
Why "just reset it" is not a diagnosis
The red reset button is a safety device, not a fix. It trips because something got too hot — a failed thermostat, a dry-fired element after a supply interruption, or a short. Pressing it back works until it trips again, usually on the day you have guests.
Working safely
There is 240 volts at the elements even when the thermostat is satisfied. The breaker comes off first, the tank is confirmed dead, and the element is only disturbed once the water is drained below its level. That sequence is why this is not a homeowner job.