No hot water? What to check before you call
Triage for a heater that has stopped making hot water — gas pilot, electric breaker, high-limit cut-out, tankless lockout — and the point where guessing stops.
First question: gas or electric
The triage differs completely by fuel, and knowing which you have saves the most time on any call.
Gas with a standing pilot. Look at the pilot through the sight glass. If it is out, the thermocouple or flame sensor has probably stopped proving the flame, and the gas valve is shutting off as designed. If it relights but dies the moment you release the button, that is the signature of a failing thermocouple, not an empty tank.
Gas with electronic ignition. The control will show a status light or a code. A unit that tries to light, fails, and locks out is reporting an ignition or flame-proving fault; repeat attempts do not fix it.
Electric. Check the breaker at the panel first, then the red high-limit button under the upper access cover if your unit has one. A breaker that holds but a tank that stays cold points to an element or thermostat; a breaker that trips immediately points to a shorted element or wiring.
Tankless. Check the display for a code, then the basics: is the gas on, is the water running hard enough to trip the unit, is the inlet filter clogged. Below its minimum flow a tankless unit will not fire at all, and that is not a fault.
The checks that are safe to do yourself
Look at the pilot or the display. Check the breaker. Confirm the gas valve at the heater is open. Open a hot tap at a basin rather than a shower, since a single-lever mixer can disguise the temperature. That is the useful limit: opening a burner assembly, testing an element or working on a gas valve is not a homeowner job.
The checks that are not
Anything involving gas piping or a gas valve, anything inside the electrical covers of a 240-volt unit, and anything requiring the tank to be drained. A dry-fired element is scrap within a minute, and a gas leak is not a diagnostic puzzle.
What the answer usually turns out to be
On gas, a thermocouple, flame sensor or dirty pilot assembly explains most sudden losses of hot water. On electric, it is an element, a thermostat or the high-limit cut-out. On tankless, flow and scale explain more faults than any failed component — which is why the code on the display is worth reading before anything else.
If the tank is more than a decade old, cold water alone is rarely the whole story; check whether the base is dry and the unit has been rumbling, because a tank on its way out tends to announce it twice.
For service on the gas side, see gas water heater repair; for an electric tank, electric water heater repair. If a pilot will not hold and you can smell gas, leave the building and call the gas utility.